10 Favorite Fall Eyeshadow Palettes

Fall is almost here. Seriously, we’re under a week away. If you’ve been here a while, you know Fall is my favorite. If you’re new here, hi! Be ready to see a TON of Fall content. The weather is cooling down here in Kentucky, and my little heart is ready to come alive. Makeup is one of my passions, and Fall is really my time to shine with beauty knowledge (I am not an expert by any means, but happy to share what I know about what I love!). I’m sharing 10 eyeshadow palettes that I own and love that are perfect for creating Fall looks (some are great for easy looks, some are great for adding a little “spice” to an eyeshadow collection).

Too Faced Pumpkin Spice

I’m starting with my favorite option. The new Too Faced Pumpkin Spice palette released, and it’s stunning. My friend Hannah bought it for me for my birthday, and I’m so grateful. This palette is absolutely gorgeous. I love that it has options – oranges, browns, purples, and some neutrals. It’s not a strictly orangy warm toned palette like most of these options, which makes my heart happy. I’ve used this palette several times already this month, and I’ve loved every single look I’ve come up with.

I also have last year’s version, and it’s really pretty too. It’s no longer available (except through Mercari or Poshmark, which is always a great option), sadly. This one is a warm toned palette, and it’s beautiful for Fall. I still use this palette frequently.

E.L.F. Pumpkin Pie

This palette is definitely the most affordable option on this list. At $3, this palette is a STEAL. The quality is very impressive (honestly, E.L.F. is a great brand and the price point is incredible). The name alone suckered me in, but I really enjoy using this palette. Check out this post to see a tutorial with this palette.

Wicked Sisters Cosmetics Hocus Pocus

This is one of the newer palettes in my collection. It’s bright, which makes it stand out in my list. I love the purples and greens and bright oranges – it’s great for creating some bright Fall looks without creating a strict warm toned look. It’s definitely pigmented, so expect a very colorful look when using this one. (Also peep the matching phone case!)

Tartelette Toasted

I’ve had this palette a couple of years, and it’s beautiful. This one is a true warm toned palette, and it’s perfect for Fall looks. Tarte palettes can be hit or miss in my opinion, but the Tartelette line is pretty solid and always a good option.

Colourpop It’s a Princess Thing

I don’t see this palette as a traditional Fall palette. It was a Christmas gift a couple of years ago, and it’s one of my favorites. There are cool and warm toned options in the palette, which makes it really versatile. Overall, it’s a pretty neutral palette, but it can be used to create some really pretty looks for Fall. And can we talk about the packaging?! The artwork on this is incredible. Check out a makeup look I’ve created using this palette here.

Sir John X Luminess Just Can’t Wait to be Queen

OK, the packaging on this one got me, and it got me good. I’m a 90’s kid at heart, so the Lion King theme suckered me in – but the packaging on this one in general is just STUNNING. I was so impressed with the artwork. The colors are a little deeper in this palette than most on this list. The browns and golds are beautiful for Fall, but I think the pops of color really accent this palette well. Check out a post with this palette included here.

NYX Warm Neutrals

I keep this palette at my desk at work. I clearly love some shades more than others. Versatile palettes are my favorites, and this palette allows so many eye looks. It’s great for a “work” palette, because you can create simple, neutral looks, but it’s also easy to create a dramatic look with this one.

Colourpop Truly Madly Deeply

Again, I am a 90’s kid, so this palette name gives me some nostalgia. This palette, like most others here, contains some really nice neutrals, but it also has some pretty shades to deepen the looks and give more depth. It’s definitely warm toned, and has some beautiful shades that are perfect for Fall eye looks.

Harry Potter X Ulta

This isn’t one specific palette, and they sadly are no longer available. Seriously, they sold out so quickly and unfortunately were never restocked (get it together please, Ulta). I wanted to include them anyway, for anyone who may have picked these up. I did a blog post talking about the Ulta X Harry Potter items (check it out here) with complete swatches. The Gryffindor palette is going to be especially beautiful for Fall looks, in my opinion.

Colourpop Blowin’ Smoke

Okay, this palette is a little different than the rest of this list. I wanted to include it, because it’s absolutely gorgeous. Fall and Winter are my favorite times to create smokey eye looks, and this palette makes that so easy. This one is right up my alley, and I love using it. Grays and blacks are my usual aesthetic (check out the fashion section of my blog to confirm this), and this palette fits that mold so well.

What’s your favorite palette on this list? Do you own any of these? Let me know what you think in the comments below!